Shalom! Welcome! Come on in, make yourself at home, have a browse. I'd be interested to hear your comments. And please do come again!

Blog EntryWhat Facebook and ironing have in commonNov 2, '07 4:46 AM
for everyone
People who know me are generally aware of my aversion to ironing. It is very near top of my list of tedious activities, a close contestant to watching paint dry.

And now I've discovered Facebook, and it only makes me appreciate Multiply more.

I won't attempt a detailed comparison, first because I haven't studied all the ins and outs of Facebook, and second because I think they are not actually trying to serve the same purposes. FB is very clearly for networking only (social or professional) whereas on Multiply there's scope for much much more.

But my first reaction to FB is: it feels like I've stumbled into a children's party, and I'm surprised to discover that there is actually something that seems too childish to me - I mean, I speak as someone who plays Ludo with her husband some evenings!

And I hate it when computers take true facts, digest them and churn out something completely untrue (and yes, it's not the computer's fault - it's only doing what some human being told it to do). For instance, there are at the moment four people with whom I have signed up as "friends" on FB (that's the FB equivalent to "contacts" here on Multiply) so when I log on I get a message at the top of my screen saying: You have 4 friends. Which is complete rubbish. The people I've linked up with there may or may not be people I count as friends, and I'm not going to try counting those out there whom I do count as friends who have so far had the sense not to sign up with FB...

And here's one of the childish things there: when you link up with someone a message appears on your screen for all your contacts to see, saying: Meirav and X are now friends. Doesn't it sound like kids at school? Oh no, mummy, Jane's not my best friend anymore, from today I'm friends with Jenny...

Another thing that narks me is this: for each contact on FB you have the option of saying where you know them from. I've got contacts there whom I know from the BMJA, so I tried ticking the appropriate box and saying BMJA. The result was a message on the screen that says something like: Meirav and X were members of the BMJA. Which makes it sound like we are no longer members of the BMJA, right? So I tried editing, and discovered that you can put dates in, to say it was from a certain year to a certain year, and under "to" you can enter "present" - but it will only allow you to do that if you enter a start year, so I had to think, and well, okay, I started going to BMJA conferences in 1999 so I entered 1999 as the start year. Which means now it says we "have been members" instead of "were members" - an improvement, certainly, but it now says: Meirav and X have been members of the BMJA since 1999, which of course is nonsense - just because I started in that year, it doesn't mean that everyone else I know from that context also did.

<sigh> Well, what's a blog page for if not for venting one's feelings... (And you can't do that so easily on FB - much easier to give someone a fish for their virtual aquarium, or "poke" someone - yuk...)

kitcarson wrote on Mar 7
Came from the Prez blog...started a FB account a month ago to see what all the fuss was about. I don't get it...half the planet is signed up there, what's wrong with these people?
meirav wrote on Mar 9
Yes, well, I went onto FB because someone I know asked me to join, but I was out of there pretty quickly! Once I realised that the whole world could see my full name - hmmm... no thanks!
lubna11367 wrote on Mar 10
hey there.. i clicked on your link from the Prez blog too.. I have been trying to get my friends and family to switch to Multiply too but cant put up a convincing enough plea..
meirav wrote on Mar 10, edited on Mar 10
Well, you are very welcome to use any of my arguments if it helps! (If you look under the Facebook tag and the Multiply tag on my site, you can see everything else I've said on this subject.)

But I think we just have to accept that we're all different, some people (probably more extrovert personality types) really enjoy FB, probably for the same reasons that we don't. We all look at the same thing, some of us react with a "Let me out of here" and others react with "Wow, great, this is fun" - so I'm glad Multiply exists for those of us who don't like to live in a goldfish bowl, but I'm also glad FB exists for those who get a kick out of sending each other virtual fish. Each to his own!
barefootmeg wrote on Apr 23
i think facebook has attracted a ton of people only because it has attracted a lot of media attention. the real problem, though, is that people join, can't stand it and leave, and never want to join another social networking site because they think they'll all be as bad as facebook.

i joined back in 2006 and was actually on there a bit before that using my husband's student email addy. but the only reason i was there was because it was a means of keeping tabs on my (college aged) cousins and what they were up to. (i've found out that they're dating someone through myspace or facebook before not because they wouldn't tell me otherwise, but because i wouldn't know to ask and they wouldn't think to tell me.)

i never liked it, from the get go. there's just no there there. and as you say meirav, it's very evident (even now after multiple executive types have joined) that it was designed with kids (college and high school ages) in mind. it really does seem like more of a place for poking someone then giggling about it rather than walking up to someone and having a conversation with them.

but how to get people over to multiply? that's one i still haven't figured out. i've had several friends join multiply so they can post replies or get email updates. but they don't actually USE their accounts and i can't figure out why. especially when they end up using shutterfly or blogger.com to do a lot of the same stuff that they could integrate over here on multiply.
snowburst wrote on Apr 23
I signed into facebook because some friends were on it. Only a few short minutes later, I canceled my account. It's just not designed to offer anything deep enough for me. I drown on the surface, but it seems that's where most people would prefer to swim.
meirav wrote on Apr 23
but how to get people over to multiply?
Yes, that is the challenge, to get people to come over and try it out and see what they're missing out on by not being here.

Some people just won't like it here and that's fine, but I'm sure, as you say, some just don't try it here because they assume all social networking sites are the same.

I guess all we can do is invite people, let them see what we've done with our sites and hope they might see what they can do with a multiply site themselves. I got here through someone inviting me - my first reaction was: what is this for? but I very soon started to see the potential, and now, under a year on, I can hardly imagine life without multiply!

My brief visit to FB (again, because someone invited me) only made me appreciate multiply even more.
meirav wrote on Apr 23
I drown on the surface, but it seems that's where most people would prefer to swim.
That is just so beautifully phrased! Yes, yes, yes, me too. Depth is where I'm comfortable, small talk is where I flounder.
Add a Comment
   
© 2008 Multiply, Inc.    About · Blog · Terms · Privacy · Corp Info · Contact Us · Help