Shalom! Welcome! Come on in, make yourself at home, have a browse. I'd be interested to hear your comments. And please do come again!

Blog EntryJokes - a dilemmaAug 28, '07 4:07 PM
for everyone
I'm not one of those PC fanatics - just a person with a conscience which annoyingly comes into play at some of the most inconvenient moments, such as when I feel like repeating a joke I've heard but then I realise that actually this joke gets a laugh at the expense of a whole load of people who have done nothing to deserve it. For instance a friend recently texted me a very funny joke about Mick and Paddy - well, it is funny, but it perpetuates the lie that Irish people are stupid, and do I really want to do that? Same goes for blondes, etc.
 
I found myself thinking about Jewish humour and how back home we used to tell jokes about people being stupid and of course they weren't racist, were they, we just told jokes about the people of Chelm, which was a mythical place where stupid people lived, right?
 
Wrong. I've just looked it up on Wikipedia and it turns out that Chelm was a real town in eastern Poland which in Jewish humour became the legendary capital of foolishness.
 
So what do we do? Can we invent a fictional place with some fictional characters so that we can tell jokes about foolishness without perpetuating stupid prejudice? Perhaps we could invent a land called Foolland, where the Foolish live?
 
Here's my feeble attempt at telling a joke without treading on anyone's toes. Let's see if it works.
 
Daft and Brush are walking home after a night out and pass the bus garage. 'Let's just steal a bus,' says Daft, not wanting to walk, and offers to keep watch. Twenty minutes later he looks in to find Brush in a flap, 'I can't find a number 7!
 
''You idiot,' says Daft, 'just take a number 9 and we'll walk from the roundabout.'

meirav wrote on Aug 28, '07
Looks like my idea of inventing a place where the Foolish lives is not so new or original. I posted this thought on another website and someone came back with this response:

Mendele Mokher Sforim, a 19th century author who wrote in Yiddish, invented a town called Glupsk (from Russian glupyj 'foolish'). The town is supposed to have been based on Berdichev (or Berdyczow ) in Poland.

Has anyone heard jokes about Glupsk?
meirav wrote on Aug 30, '07
Here's another idea for a way round this problem: I can tell the joke as if it were about myself (e.g. a friend and I were on our way back from the pub and decided to steal a bus...) or about a fictitious friend (e.g. a friend tells me she walked into a bar - shame she didn't see it).

What do you think?
tselly wrote on Sep 1, '07
I once heard from an Englishman that the English version of Chelm is called Gotham. Is there such a place in England? There is in the US: New York City.
meirav wrote on Sep 7, '07
Well - I'd never heard of it, but with the help of Google I found this: http://www.gothamvillage.co.uk/tales.htm
Add a Comment
   
© 2008 Multiply, Inc.    About · Blog · Terms · Privacy · Corp Info · Contact Us · Help